If you need one “overall” pick based on the provided scoring, the ADATA HD710 Pro narrowly comes out ahead thanks to its standout durability/build scores, portable external convenience, and broad compatibility positioning. It’s the more natural choice for people who carry storage around, want a tougher enclosure, and prefer simple plug-in use.
However, the ADATA Ultimate SU630 is often the better choice in practice for users upgrading an older PC or laptop, because it scores higher for speed/performance/value and reviews consistently describe a noticeably faster system after installation. Choose the SU630 when internal performance matters most, and choose the HD710 Pro when rugged external backups and portability are the priority.